Tag: Cereals

Arable Roundup

Grain prices fell considerably during February.  The May-24 UK Feed Wheat Futures contract started the Month at £175 per tonne, as of 24th February the same contract was worth £164 per tonne.  It is a similar story for the 2024 crop, with November-24 Futures £9 per tonne lower on the month.

The direction of the UK market is driven by the availability of global grains.  Concern had been building about dry conditions in South America hindering planting progress.  However, both Brazil and Argentina have received rainfall and planting of maize and soyabeans has progressed.  Argentina is forecast to harvest an additional 22.5 million tonnes of maize in 2023/24 compared to 2022/23 (when it was affected by a widespread drought).  Brazilian grain and oilseed production forecast have fallen.  However, the country is still expected to harvest a combined 300 million tonnes of cereals and oilseeds; the second largest harvest on record.

Furthermore, grain prices are weighed down by cheap Black Sea wheat, slow US grain and oilseed exports, and the large sold position held by speculative traders in US grain futures.

Looking ahead to the 2024 UK harvest, the window of opportunity for further winter wheat plantings, prior to latest safe sowing dates, is closing.  Heavier ground is still sodden, especially across the East Midlands.  Crops on lighter land look far better.  UK growers face the prospect of smaller crops being sold at lower prices.  The poor outlook for the 2024 harvest is increasingly accounted for in grain prices.  Looking at the gap between old crop and new crop wheat futures (May-24 versus November-24), the new crop is worth almost £19 per tonne more that the old crop.  This time last year the November crop (November-23) was worth just £3 per tonne more than the old crop (May-23).

UK Feed Wheat Futures Chart

Source: AHDB

Farmgate grain prices have reflected the wider trend in futures, as shown in Key Farm Facts.  The UK still has ample old crop wheat and barley stocks, with prices uncompetitive into export markets.

Grain Market Update

Like the water sat on many headlands around the country, old crop wheat markets could rightly be described as stagnant!

Looking back across the May-23 UK feed wheat futures market, prices have been stuck in a channel from £194 to £204 per tonne since the beginning of September.  Prices are sitting in the bottom of that band presently and showing little sign of moving back towards the top.  This is partly driven by readily available Black Sea grain, keeping prices pressured.

The old crop market is also influenced by a large global maize crop, with the US harvest all but complete.  In November, the USDA added a further four million tonnes to its production forecast for the US, citing improved yields.  In total a further 2.5 million tonnes have been added to global maize ending stocks, compared to October’s forecast.  Ending stocks of maize, globally, are up 15 million tonnes year-on-year.

The new crop market is more interesting, unless you are looking out on waterlogged crops.  Poor weather conditions have led to estimates of a 5-10% decline in wheat area across the UK, France, Germany, and Ukraine (Openfield).  This is driving an £11 per tonne premium for November 2024, over current May prices.  Concerns are built into new crop pricing.  It will take a worsening of conditions to keep prices supported.

In the UK, grain markets are lacking activity.  There are reports of weaker demand for bioethanol production.  UK wheat prices are uncompetitive in export markets and prices are under pressure (see Key Farm Facts).  Milling premiums remain elevated.

Feed barley is at a more than £20 per tonne discount to feed wheat.  However inclusions in animal feed rations are already high.  As such, barley prices need to be competitive into export markets to generate extra sales.  Old crop malting barley premiums remain high.  With concern over winter wheat plantings, and a subsequent increase in spring barley plantings likely, new crop premiums may be lower.

Oilseed rape prices are benefitting from uncertainty over planting of soyabeans in South America.  The north of Brazil remains very dry, while planting progress in the south of Brazil has been delayed by heavy rains.  The pace has improved towards the end of November but remains behind average. While this is supporting oilseeds now, it could also hinder the maize plantings which follow soyabeans in spring, offering future support to grains.

UK Arable Outlook

As harvest draws nearer, UK wheat prices have increased, supported by concerns for US maize and prolonged dryness in Northern Europe (see preceding article).  In the week ending 23rd June 2023, ex-farm feed wheat was quoted at £175 per tonne; up almost £15 per tonne on the beginning of the month, but still just behind the May average of £176 per tonne.

AHDB Corn Returns data shows a positive carry into new crop prices, with feed wheat for September delivery averaging £196 per tonne in the week ending 22nd June.  Milling wheat continues to command a strong premium of nearly £66 per tonne, with the price quoted at £241 per tonne, ex-farm.

Barley prices have not gained to the same degree as wheat prices, up £8 per tonne on the beginning of June.  Ex-farm barley is quoted at £156 per tonne – demand for old crop feed barley has increased slightly but remains slow.  The UK is currently not competitive into export markets.  This could continue to pressure prices with a large carryout expected from harvest 2022, and barley now ripening and harvest not far away in the South and East.

Oilseed rape values had strengthened through June, reaching £346 per tonne in the middle of the month, before falling again.  Weaker than expected biofuel mandates in the US pressured soyabean oil prices, dragging the wider vegetable oils complex lower.  Subsequently, ex-farm oilseed rape was quoted at £326 per tonne on 23rd June.

Pulse prices picked up during the month with some renewed demand, but selling reportedly remained limited.  Both feed beans and feed peas were quoted at £241 per tonne, on 23rd June.

UK Arable Markets

UK winter arable crops are looking in good order, according to a recent AHDB Crop Condition Survey, conducted at the end of March.  That said, March was drier than normal, a trend which has continued through April.  The long-range weather forecast suggests dry weather will continue for most areas of the UK.  This may start to impact potential yield if it carries on for a few more weeks.

UK arable markets have followed the global trend.  Nearby ex-farm feed wheat prices gave moved up to £308.20 per tonne in the week ending 22nd April 2022. Prices had fallen coming into April but have gone on to set new highs.

The price of ex-farm feed barley has narrowed the discount to wheat throughout April.  In the week ending 22nd April, nearby feed barley was quoted at £303 per tonne.  Wheat and barley prices have now risen by more than £83 and £94 per tonne respectively since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

The rise in prices has helped to offset some of the rise in input costs, with fuel and fertiliser experiencing sizeable uplifts.  There are indications that the price of ammonium nitrate has now fallen back from recent highs.  But high input costs will still represent a significant challenge for the 2023 crop.  New crop UK feed wheat futures have been trading at around £250 per tonne since the middle of April.  This may offer a useful hedge against high input prices for the coming season.

Most arable farmers will have already ordered their spring fertiliser – often some months ago.  There have been reports of availability issues for orders made this spring.  However, there is currently no shortage of fertiliser in the UK.  In fact, the main UK manufacturer is having trouble selling what is producing (perhaps not surprising given current prices) and is exporting considerable tonnages.  The issue with delivery and long order times are mainly for those ordering part loads and are largely due to logistics.  Those with a less-than-stellar credit history may also struggle.  Manufacturers and merchants are having to deal with their own cashflow pressures and do not want any bad or late debts.   

Rapeseed prices have also risen, with Ukraine a key producer of sunflowers and rapeseed.  Ex-farm oilseed rape prices are quoted at more than £845 per tonne; a 40% increase since 25th February.

One crop that has not seen the same degree of price rise is beans, which were quoted at £302 per tonne, ex-farm. This is the first time beans have been quoted at a discount to barley since December 2006, demand for feed beans by UK consumers is reportedly lacking.

OSR Area to Rise

The results of the annual Early Bird Survey of UK planted intentions show a 13% rise in rapeseed area for harvest 2022, at 345,000 hectares.  The increase is not surprising given how firm rapeseed prices are.  But, the fact the increase is not greater, reflects the large increases in rapeseed prices since mid-September.  This is after most planting has been completed.

The area of arable fallow is also seen increasing year-on-year.  This is a possible reflection of the surging cost of inputs this season, which will challenge many margins.  With high nitrogen costs we may have expected to see an increase in the area planted to leguminous crops.  However, this is not the case, and the area planted to pulses is forecast to fall by 5%.  As with OSR, this is likely driven by the timing of price rises.

Unsurprisingly, wheat remains a firm feature in the rotation.  The area planted to the crop is set to rise for the second year in a row, following the disastrous 2020 harvest.  The area is seen rising to 1.81 million hectares.  This is slightly down on the 1.82 million hectare crop for 2019.  This will go further to easing the tight domestic market we have now, following the 2020 crop.

With a rise in the area planted to wheat and OSR, barley and oats look set to lose out.  The total area intended to be planted to barley is down 4% at 1.10 million hectares year-on-year.  Area is also seen down 101 thousand hectares on the five-year average.  With grain prices firm it is arguably no surprise that spring acreage is down 8%, whilst winter area is seen up 4%.

If the intended area planted to barley is realised, then we could see the narrow discount of barley to wheat continue.  The barley market is tight at present in the UK, and a reduced acreage would do little to replenish stocks.

It is worth highlighting at this stage these figures represent intentions, rather than confirmed plantings.  Spring acreages are still very much open to change, dependent on the price of both outputs and inputs (especially this season).

 

Harvest 2021

Following the poor crop of 2020, the harvest of 2021 was always likely to yield more positive results.  However, initial output figures from Defra were lower than some had expected.  The table below highlights the arable results from the 2021 Survey of Agriculture and Horticulture, showing crop production and area figures for the main crops in the UK.  The data is provisional, with final results due to be published on 16th December.  Figures for both Wales and Northern Ireland have been rolled forward from last season.

Wheat production was seen increasing by 45% year-on-year to just over 14 million tonnes.  This was primarily driven by a rebound in area following the difficult drilling campaign in 2020.  That said, average yields were lower than some had expected.  Yields in the south and east of England were seeming affected by the damp and dull summer.  Lower bushel weights and higher moistures were seen for many; Defra standardize wheat production to a 14.5% moisture.

For barley, lower production is no surprise, particularly given the large reduction in spring barley area.  The drop in area is countered by stronger yields, particularly for Scottish spring barley.  As a result, total barley output is just over 190,000 tonnes lower than the 2016-20 average at 7.1 million tonnes.

Once again, the challenges for oilseed rape (OSR) are evident.  With cabbage stem flea beetle (CSFB) still a huge challenge for many growers, the area planted to the crop fell to just 306,000 hectares.  This means the area planted to the crop has now fallen 399,000 hectares in the last ten years.  Even with an improvement in yield, production is seen below 1 million tonnes for the first time since 1989.  With OSR prices very firm at planting, will we see a rebound in acreage, despite the challenges of establishing the crop?

Oats have continued to gain acreage in recent years, owing in part to the challenges of growing OSR.  Production increased for the third year in a row.

Grain Market Thoughts

The world grain and oilseed markets remain dominated by a seemingly insatiable appetite by China to import ever-increasing tonnages of all grains and other commodities.  It has been importing most of the world’s traded soybeans for many years now but has only recently entered the market for colossal amounts of maize and wheat too.  This demonstrates that the Chinese agricultural policy of hundreds of years of being self-sufficient in grains is well and truly finished.  According to statistics published monthly by the USDA, the Chinese now hold not only two thirds of global maize stocks (9-months’ Chinese demand), but also 50% of global wheat stocks, 35% of soybeans 60% of rice stocks and 40% of the cotton.  Something is going on.  Some global food supply reports suggest China is about to experience a major food shortage and global food prices are therefore likely to rise any time soon.  Other reports suggest the stock levels are quite wrong and China is not hoarding quite so much.  The truth is likely to be that even the USDA does not really know for sure what China has (perhaps the Chinese cannot be so sure), and of course, being part of the US Government, the USDA could have another agenda, but it’s the best information we have.  China did build up similar stock levels at the turn of the Millennium, so it is not unprecedented.  It subsequently then ran down stocks, contributing to a bearish grain market for some years.

This time of year, crop reports from around the world are a major factor in the pricing of the new crop.  People might look first at the eye-catching old crop prices, but as most of that will be sold by now (or at least committed and priced), the new crop is of more significance.  November 2021 futures closed on the 25th March at £33 per tonne lower than May 2021, at £166 per tonne.  Russian analysts have recently reported good growing conditions for their wheat and increased their tonnage projection by 3 million tonnes (to 79 million) despite relatively poor crop ratings.  The Ukrainians too have done the same, reporting their wheat is in an excellent state and the positive reports travel through Europe too with Strategie Grains also posting good yield expectations for European wheat crops.  Despite the avid export of all grains to China, it is these positive prospects for production that has taken the edge off the grain prices in the last month.

New crop barley, whilst still having a larger discount to feed wheat than most years, has at least fallen to £15-£20 per tonne from feed wheat which compares favourably against the £30+ discount for old crop.  Not only is the production far lower than last year, but also we can hope that come June, people might start drinking more beer again so the malting industry might be rekindled.

The oat market took a boost this month with news that a new oat buyer is planning to set up in Peterborough.  Oatly, a Swedish company will make milk from oats to supply the growing market for animal-milk alternatives (see below). Farmers have found oats a very useful crop agronomically in recent years, but held back from growing it as few buyers have been in the market, so perhaps this will encourage a greater cropped area.

Oilseed rape for post-harvest looks as encouraging as this season’s prices have proven to be.  Perhaps some growers who opted away from the crop will be looking at these bid prices wishing they had tried growing it again.  Perhaps next season, the crop will experience a resurgence of area cropped.  The supply and demand table continues to look tight for new crop because, despite a likely rise in production from Canada, the largest producer, the other main regions (particularly Ukraine and Australia) look set to be lower.  Europe will remain in deficit too with large planted area reductions throughout the continent.

Demand for pulses has fallen away this month, as is often the case in March, as the Australian crop starts reaching the North African buyers.  The market will be thin from now on, and occasionally closed.

Arable Markets

Overall Comment

Whilst in some counties over the last week the weather has been harsh, over the country it appears overall, December has so far been considerably ‘less wet’ than the previous 3 months. But with soils already saturated it does not take much to keep the land impassable. Now the crops are mostly dormant meaning nothing is transpiring the water away, and minimal evaporation is taking place either as temperatures are too low with high humidity. In other words, a millimetre of rain here and there has been topping up the already sodden soils. Cold dry frosts have also been scarce this autumn, meaning that grain conditioning in store has been difficult. Some samples, particularly of barley have been losing premiums because of infestations. Managing grain quality will become increasingly difficult this winter.

Wheat

Nevertheless, the AHDB has reported they consider the winter wheat planted area has now risen to about 60 of intended plantings, suggesting progress of about 5% since the last of these bulletins was published. Clearly, at this rate, and if weather conditions do not change, there will still be about 30% of the planned winter wheat area undrilled at the end of February; about the end of the window available for drilling most of the varieties currently sat in bags in farm barns around the country.

UK grain traders have had a challenging time this season, unable to book grain exports past the official Brexit dates. For a year with a large crop to sell, this has affected market prices. Perhaps some clarity in the New Year will facilitate the rest of the marketing campaign.

Barley

Old crop markets are asleep already in preparation for the Christmas break. Its not even planted yet, but the prices for the 2020 crop have not been great, with expectations of very large UK and EU crops. Few buyers are buying much new crop yet, as prices are so bearish. Certainty regarding the EU departure will support the buying confidence.  Seed traders have been gathering what spring barley tonnages they can and, between them, it appears there is enough available for in excess of a million hectares to go in the ground, as soon as conditions allow. This would be the highest spring barley crop since 1988, and the largest total barley crop since 1990; that is, assuming it is dry enough to drill by then.

Oilseed Rape

Global demand for vegetable oils is strong. The Chinese still demand vast tonnages of soybeans, despite millions of its pigs, who et the meal) have been slaughtered because of African Swine Fever. This might shift the balance of demand between oil and meal which would favour crops like oilseed rape that have a higher oil content. Certainly, oilseed rape has done quite well over the last month, regardless of the overall movements of sterling.

Pulses

Pulses trade quickly in the first half of a marketing year, then slow down for the second half. The export market for pulses for this season is quickly reaching that point, partly as the Australian crop will be competing strongly come January, and also because of customs clearance deadlines in North Africa.

 

 

Combinable Crop Situation

Oilseed rape production in the EU has not been so low since the EU the EU expanded to 27  Member States.  The introduction of Croatia in 2013 had minimal impact on the OSR supply and demand tables, but Bulgaria and particularly Romania, which joined in 2007, account for about as much production as the UK does.  The crop this year is thought (for example by Coceral) to be about 12% to 13% lower than last year, and as much as 29% lower than the highest production year of 2014.  In fact, since then, four out of the five years have incurred declines in OSR crop size.

This means that this year, the EU (including the UK in this description) will be importing oilseed rape from elsewhere.  Some have suggested 6 million tonnes of will be required.  At the same time, regulations on importing biodiesel produced from palm oil is becoming more expensive with duties rising.  Additionally, the rise of crude oil prices following the attacks on Saudi refineries have also led to rises in vegetable oil markets.  These factors have come together to support oilseed rape prices in recent weeks on European markets.

In the meantime, Sterling has gaining strength by 5% against the Euro in the light of rising expectations of a Brexit deal since early August.  This has wiped out any gains in the UK OSR markets. This (relatively modest) currency shift demonstrates just how dominant the value of the Pound is on agricultural prices.  We have no influence on the value of Sterling and minimal ability to predict accurately.

Taking this logic a little further, it follows that as soon as a decision on the type of Brexit is reached, whether Deal, No Deal or even no-Brexit, the impact on the value of our currency will almost inevitably be instant and dramatic; probably far more than 5% in either direction, depending on outcome.  In the short term, the profitability of cereal farming post Brexit-decision will be led by currency shifts.  Any other factors might be dwarfed by this one thing.

Exporters have been working round the clock to export as much wheat and barley from the UK’s exportable surplus since harvest.  Their deadline is 31st October as they do not know what the tariff rates will be after then.  Conveniently, there has been considerable buying interest from many of the large cereal buyers, mainly in North Africa including Algeria, Tunisia and Egypt.  These countries don’t buy from the UK, but they have occupied other exporters’ minds whilst UK traders have focused on our traditional Iberian markets.  This has helped UK grain prices to hold up, in the face of stronger Pound (see above).  Yet the EU wheat crop is considerably higher than last year and the US cereals prices (especially maize) have been falling this month.  The urgency of exporters to get stocks off farms and onto boats has supported prices.

Bean prices are also holding up well.  The urgency to export the (considerable) surplus is smaller, both as much of the bean export goes outside the EU anyway, and also as the tariff rate to the EU is far smaller.  In any case, the trade has struggled this year to find much that is of food grade, most ending up in feed bins.

Arable Market Thoughts

It never rains, it always pours!  By early June, some were concerned about the dry soil conditions, by the end, the concern was flooding.  Most of the crops that had been flattened have picked up, but not all, increasing the risks of Fusarium.  Combinable crops now require sunshine to help them ripen with good quality and bushel weights.

The other thing that has fallen over this month (which we had been warning would happen) is the premium that the old crop wheat carried over new crop.  Sooner or later the two crop prices have to merge, and they did this decisively in June.  In fact old crop long-holders will be feeling frustrated by the chart clearly showing July 2019 futures values in January of £180 now being worth £145.  Also, new crop wheat prices have taken a sharp turn upwards, now clearly ahead of old crop.  This will encourage any buyers to take short term cover and close the gap.  Farmer sellers with adequate storage might be tempted to carry the grain over if it is in satisfactory condition.

Globally, the wheat crop is overall healthy and abundant, with expectations from the International Grains Council that it will outstrip consumption to leave slightly higher stocks this coming season.  This has helped explain the price falls in the market.  Maize though, the main combinable crop in the world, is thought abundant but not likely to match annual demand, so stock levels are expected (by the IGC) to decline again this year.  This will be the third decline since 2016/17 from 363 to 284 million tonnes; a substantial fall.

Soybean stocks are also thought likely to return a small decline in physical stock level after the 2019/20 season, although only by 1 million tonnes.  This is a tiny change after such a sharp rise in stock from 25 million tonnes to the current 53 million in only six years.  The question of how much oilseed rape will be grown in the UK is concerning many; whilst we have reported the poor OSR conditions on many farms this year, we have not pointed out that other arable farmers are quietly very happy with the condition of theirs. Some has been grubbed and replaced, other fields are looking excellent.

Bean crops are largely looking good throughout the country, and with new crop reaching good prices, perhaps now is the time to book some in.  Currently, we would expect bean crops to outperform their overall dismal performance from last year.